Scariest Creepypasta Characters

Creepypasta was designed to make the fear crawl up our backs. The characters are so real in our imagination, so scary and yet so addictive. Some may not look that scary, but their personalities and sick character traits compensate the lack of horrible looks. The fact that some of the characters are based on the real people that have experienced real events makes the whole fact of reading the story even more horrifying. RankTopTen proudly presents the list of creepypasta characters that the users find the scariest. Join the creepy party, find the scariest thing on the chart and vote for it, increasing its popularity.


Laughing Jack

Laughing Jack is the titular antagonist of the creepypasta story of the same name and its prequel, "The Origin of Laughing Jack". His origins date back to 1800's England, where he was created by a guardian angel as a "not so imaginary friend" for Isaac Grossman, an extremely lonely child that was often abused by his parents (his mother in particular)


The Rake

During the summer of 2003, events in the northeastern United States involving a strange, human-like creature sparked brief local media interest before an apparent blackout was enacted. The Rake best creepypasta Little or no information was left intact, as most online and written accounts of the creature were mysteriously destroyed. Primarily focused in rural New York state and once found in Idaho, self proclaimed witnesses told stories of their encounters with a creature of unknown origin. Emotions ranged from extremely traumatic levels of fright and discomfort, to an almost childlike sense of playfulness and curiosity. While their published versions are no longer on record, the memories remained powerful. Several of the involved parties began looking for answers that year.

Mr. Bear (1999)

Jeff the Killer

Jeffrey "Jeff" Woods (also known as Jeff the Killer) is the titular main protagonist (later antagonist) of the Creepypasta of the same name who loses his sanity and begins killing to satisfy his homicidal urges. He has become one of the largest Creepypasta icons to date, even rivaling Slender Man. Jeff was a 13-year-old boy, who was a caring young man who loved his brother Liu. As a killer, all that changed and he became a vengeful, dangerous, and bloodthirsty psychopath.

Ben Statue

Eyeless Jack

Eyeless Jack is one of the most frightening Creepypasta characters. He used to be an ordinary guy, who met a girl; she was a member of demon’s cult. The boy was sacrificed. During the ritual, he lost his eyes, and now he has black holes instead of them. Jack eats human organs; his favorite delicacy is kidneys. Around midnight that night, Mitch wakes to see Eyeless Jack over his bed, wearing a blue mask with black liquid dripping from empty eye sockets behind the mask. Mitch manages to grab his camera and take a picture before Jack attacks, clawing at his chest. Mitch escapes and flees into the woods, where he trips and is knocked unconscious. When Mitch awakens in the hospital, it is revealed to him that Edwin had been killed the previous night. His parents drive him to the house to collect his belongings. When he enters, Mitch sees Edwin's corpse and a small object laying next to it. He observes it to find that it is his kidney with a bite taken out of it, covered in a black substance.




Slender Man

He is popularly viewed as some sort of malevolent demon that abducts and psychologically traumatizes people, particularly children. Though what he does with them is unknown, it is speculated he kills them, or takes them to another dimension. In some versions of the legend, he will impale captured victims on tree branches and save them for later skinning and consumption. It is widely considered that his "faceless pale man in a suit" persona is really a smaller form, and that his true form is beyond comprehension for mortals. It is also thought that he may have a long-term (possibly cataclysmic) goal in mind, but this is uncertain. He is widely recognized as a sort of pop culture icon and also a very controversial figure, and is a prime example of a Creepypasta villain at its best, being featured in many fictional stories around the web. Although Slender Man's main goals are clear, motives are not.Some believe him to be real and sightings have been reported from diverse locations.


BEN Drowned

BEN (also known as Ben Drowned creepypasta and Haunted Majora's Mask) is a famous Creepypasta (and later, an alternate reality game) created by Alex Hall, also known as "Jadusable". He's a ghost that haunts the game: Legend of Zelda Majora's Mask. Follow his story as his story gets told. BEN wears a Link outfit, but his eyes are black, except the pupils are red, and bleeding. He's very into video games, but he loses sometimes.


Ticci Toby

Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers or Ticci-Toby wasn't always a normal kid while growing up. Follow his journey through loss, abusement, and disorders. Toby wears a pattern color/blue sweater, jeans, a black sweater underneath the first sweater, Converse, gloves, a mouth guard, and some goggles. He has a mouth guard, due to that his mouth is somehow cut open. His weapon is his 2 hatchets"', and one of them has an orange handle.


Smile Dog

What is behind the picture you see in your worst nightmares the horrors that you seek lie right in the eye of the Smiling Dog Or does it?


Bloody Painter

Helen Otis or Bloody Painter was once a loner at school who became a victim of bullying. Follow his journey through being a loner, bullied, and snapped. Helen wears a blue jacket, with a yellow happy face pin. His hands are covered with black gloves, with blood on them. He wears a white mask, with a bloody smile on it, and black holes for the eyes. His weapon is a paintbrush knife.

Grey Man
Rap Rat
Seed Eater
Pinkamena Diane Pie
Abounded by Disney Mickey Mouse Costume

You mean Suicide Mouse

The Smiling Girl


It is hard to find somebody as much mysterious among Creepypasta characters as “He Who Waits Behind The Walls,” a real incarnation of darkness. Zalgo has seven mouths, six of which speaks in different languages, and the seventh can sing. When the song of the seventh mouth sounds, the end of the world will begin.

The Sandman
Happy Appy
Tails Doll
The Girl in The Photograph
Jason the Toymaker
Mr. Widemouth
Sally Williams
Frank (Donnie Darko)
Mother's Call